In a real-world engagement, the Eurofighter is likely to win the day despite the Tomcat’s still impressive capabilities, maneuverability, and, surprisingly, higher top speed. The technology of its computer-aided flight systems allows the Typhoon to out-maneuver the swing-wing F-14. The weapons of the Typhoon are significantly superior, not only thanks to the missiles themselves, but also the sensors and control systems have the benefits of decades of advances in digital technology.
The Grumman F-14 Tomcat is surpassed by the Eurofighter Typhoon in terms of sensors, agility, and survivability. It detects targets long before the F-14 can react, thanks to its Captor-E AESA radar and PIRATE infrared system. While the Tomcat’s older Sidewinders and Phoenixes have limitations, the Typhoon’s helmet-sighted Meteor and IRIS-T missiles provide lethal range and off-axis targeting capability.
Carbon-fiber and canard-delta aerodynamics paired with digital flight controls, and a higher thrust-to-weight ratio let the Eurofighter sustain brutal maneuvers the variable-sweep Tomcat can’t match. Smaller radar cross-section, automatic electronic countermeasures, and super-cruise capability seal the advantage in any engagement scenario. During joint-exercise training, the Typhoon has actually scored kills on everything from US Navy F/A-18 Super Hornets to Air Force F-35 Lightning II, and F-22 Raptor stealth fighters.
Radar: BVR Missileers Of Different Eras
In BVR (Beyond Visual Range) air combat, pilots attack enemy aircraft without being able to see them by using long-range radar and air-to-air missiles, usually at distances of more than 30 to 50 kilometers. To gain the edge while preventing the enemy from doing the same, the basic idea is to use sensors and networked capabilities to achieve an offensive weapons solution on an opponent from a distance where they can’t see you yet.
The Typhoon leverages power and speed as well as long-range weapons with advanced targeting features. It exploits its large nose section so its active electronically scanned array (AESA) array sweeps wide expanses of airspace rapidly. Eurofighter.com says the current system has a “field of view that is some 50% wider than traditional fixed plate systems.”
Eurofighter Typhoon is a multinational effort between the UK, Germany, Italy, and Spain. Its design originally specialized in air superiority with a later addition of ground-attack capability. The original radar was mechanically scanned (Captor-M) but has since evolved into an electronically scanned array (Captor-E).
F-14A Tomcat (AWG-9) |
Eurofighter Typhoon (ECRS) |
---|---|
Six basic working modes, four of which were pulse-Doppler. |
Repositionable AESA array for wide field of regard. |
19 transmission channels for pulse-Doppler search signals, of which 6 for guidance of AIM-54 missiles, and 5 for AIM-7s. |
Electronic warfare and jamming features. |
Track-While-Scan (TWS) allowed the radar to maintain a search pattern while simultaneously tracking multiple targets. |
Passive detection via Pirate Infrared Sensor. |
Pulse-Doppler Search (PDS) for detecting bomber-sized targets from very long distances. |
Automated defensive aids (DASS) for threat response. |
Pulse-Doppler Single Target Track (PDSTT) for focused tracking on a single, high-priority target. |
Modular design allowing ongoing hardware and software updates. |
Designed to attack and destroy enemy aircraft at night and in any weather, the F-14 Tomcat is a two-seat, supersonic, twin-engine, swing-wing fighter. The F-14 may use its weapons control system to track up to 24 targets at once and launch six Phoenix AIM-54A missile attacks. The long-range Phoenix missile can fire at targets up to 80 miles away. A variety of other air intercept missiles, rockets, and bombs are also options in the Tomcat arsenal.
The F-14’s AWG-9 was actually the most powerful radar equipped to a fighter jet until Lockheed Martin’s F-22 Raptor entered service in 2005, according to the Aviation Geek Club. The Tomcat was specifically made for the purpose of destroying high-flying, supersonic Soviet bombers and fighters in a Cold War scenario, which made it nearly as high-performance as the McDonnell Douglas F-15 Eagle.
By The Numbers: A Generational Difference
Spain, Italy, Germany, and the United Kingdom are the four founding Eurofighter partner nations. These four nations work together to design and produce the Eurofighter through a partnership between their top defense and aerospace firms, including Leonardo, BAE Systems, and Airbus. The Eurofighter’s generations are called production “tranches,” each one adding new systems and other types of updates.
Tranche 1 aircraft, delivered from 2003, were optimized for air-to-air missions. Only the final Block 5 standard featured an air-to-surface configuration via a LITENING III targeting pod and a helmet-mounted sight. Tranche 2 followed in 2008 with stronger airframes and far more capable mission computers. Those upgrades allowed for “swing-role” loads such as Storm Shadow cruise missiles, Brimstone, JDAM, Paveway IV, and eventually the Meteor beyond-visual-range (BVR) missile.
Tranche 4, ordered in 2020 for Germany and subsequently for Spain, Kuwait, and Qatar, is the first Typhoon built around an AESA radar, Leonardo’s ECRS Mk 1. It also features refreshed cockpit displays, improved communications, and digital radio-frequency memory jamming while retaining growth space for stand-off SPEAR 3 missiles and electronic-attack pods.
Here are the key performance metrics of the Eurofighter Typhoon per Eurojet.de:
Spec |
Eurofighter Typhoon |
---|---|
Wingspan |
35 ft 11 in (10.95 m) |
Length |
52 ft 4 in (15.96 m) |
Height |
17 ft 4 in (5.28 m) |
Wing Area |
551.1 square ft (51.2 m2) |
Maximum Speed |
Mach 2.0 (1,522 mph, 2,495 kmh) at altitude |
With variable geometry wings that maximize performance across its flight envelope, the Navy’s F-14 wings can be moved automatically or manually, enabling it to intercept at over Mach 2 and land on the decks of aircraft carriers. Navigation, target acquisition, ECM, and weapon firing are the responsibilities of the pilot and radar intercept officer (RIO).
Six long-range AIM-54A Phoenix missiles are guided by the fighter’s AWG-9 weapons control system against six long-range threat aircraft. Its variable-sweep wings allow it to engage in medium-range combat with Sparrow missiles, Sidewinders, and a 20mm for dogfighting. Below are the key specifications of the F-14:
Spec |
Grumman F-14A |
---|---|
Length |
62 ft 9 in (19.1 m) |
Wingspan |
Spread: 64 ft (19.55 m) Swept: 38 ft (11.58 m) |
Maximum Speed |
Mach 2.34 (1,781 mph, 2,485 km/h) at altitude |
Service Ceiling |
50,000+ ft (15,200 m) |
Rate of Climb |
>45,000 ft/min (229 m/s) |
Verdict: Technology Wins The Day
Long before the pilots can see each other, their aircraft would already be dueling in the invisible domain of emissions and targeting. Knowing that the Tomcat’s great equalizer is the long-range Phoenix, the Typhoon jockey would need to press first, briefly opening the radar to its full power, tag the target with a single burst, then hand guidance off to a ramjet-powered Meteor. Seconds later, he shuts the transmitter down entirely and lets the missile guide itself. The Phoenix would have to fight its way through towed decoys, digital noise, and a target that has already begun to change altitude and vector.
By the time the older Tomcat missile transitions to active homing, it finds its seeker head swimming in jamming and a quarry that has slid off-axis. The Meteor, meanwhile, is barreling at more than Mach three, its motor burning late into the terminal phase. There is still a chance that later iterations of the Tomcat could put up a good fight, as Doug ‘Boog’ Denneny, a former TOPGUN Instructor and F-14 RIO/Super Hornet WSO, told Hush-Kit:
“The AIM-54C+ had a phenomenal seeker with digital processing tricks that would blow your mind, and with a large active radar in its nose and high power out, could go active way out at range, and allow the TOMCAT to turn (at Mach 2 it’s a big turn!) and run away…possibly before the METEOR could run it down.”
The Merge: Knife Fighting With Supersonic Jets
If the Tomcat lives to merge, here the age gap between the airframes shows more starkly than anywhere else. The Typhoon’s canard-delta aerodynamics, and digitally boosted flight controls allow sustained nine G spirals with minimal energy loss. Against that, the Tomcat, whose variable-sweep wings are now fully forward, cannot risk more than a few G’s for very long without overstressing a design from the 1960s.
Every hard pull for a clean shot makes the F-14 slower, leaving two glowing F110 exhausts right where the Eurofighter’s PIRATE infrared sensor wants them. The Typhoon’s helmet cueing system lets the pilot look through the canopy frames, command an IRIS-T to lock far off boresight, and launch even under heavy G’s.
Should the duel somehow continue into a second merge, the Typhoon remains at an advantage. Even with a single pilot, they are less task-saturated thanks to sensor fusion. Its fuel advantage is higher because afterburners are used less, and its smaller radar cross-section keeps distant supporting fighters or an E-2 Hawkeye from supporting the Tomcat. Despite the nostalgia of swing-wings and the romance of “Top Gun,” the Typhoon brings something far more decisive: two decades of advances in sensors, data processing, aerodynamics, and electronic warfare.
Despite the shortcomings of the Tomcat in the modern era, it earned the trust of its pilots. A Navy veteran pilot who flew both the F-14 and F-18, John Tartaglione, was quoted by the National Security Journal, giving his opinion on which he would prefer to carry him into battle:
“The Hornet was far more nimble than the Tomcat, but the Hornet did not have the range, endurance, or speed of a Tomcat. But were I to go into combat, I would much rather be in the Tomcat. My RIO and I were a great team. Having that extra set of eyes was invaluable. One afternoon, my wingman and I engaged a pair of Libyan MIG23s. During the engagement, I lost sight of one of the MIGs. While I kept my eyes on the Libyan in front of me, I knew my RIO could help me to get my eyes on the other MIG. That extra set of eyes is invaluable when all hell breaks loose.”